THE TEST WILL REVEAL YOUR LACK AND A NECESSITY TO TRAIN
ENTER INTO THE REAL-LIFE ARENA, FAIL AND BEGIN AGAIN AND AGAIN
Disagreement is not the problem.
Losing respect is.
Two people can stand on opposite sides of an issue…
and still walk away wiser.
I like exchanging ideas.
Thoughts.
Observations.
Experiences.
Different points of view.
Good conversation can actually GO somewhere.
It can:
teach,
challenge,
open,
correct,
and sometimes create a breakthrough.
Arguing?
I have yet to see the value in that.
PAUSE FOR CAUSE.
Disagreeing is one thing.
Trying to defeat the person is another.
PASSIONATE POINTS OF VIEW?
People often let passion drive the whole vehicle.
Understanding gets tossed in the trunk.
LOL.
We forget something simple:
people are not all standing in the same place mentally, emotionally, spiritually, politically, socially or professionally.
Different backgrounds.
Different experiences.
Different timing.
Different fears.
Different hopes.
So naturally…
we are not all going to see and hear the same thing the same way.
Why should we expect that?
BECOMING A GOOD BICKERER?
I believe we should share our experiences when appropriate.
Put them on the table.
Offer them.
Let others inspect them.
If somebody wants to know more…
good.
If they disagree…
also good.
Why does disagreement have to become combat?
What is gained by:
interrupting,
raising voices,
mocking,
pushing,
repeating,
or trying to corner somebody?
That is not dialogue.
That is bickering with better vocabulary.
LOL.
And if you practice it long enough…
you may become very skilled at winning arguments…
while losing people.
DESIRE LEVELS ARE SUBJECTIVE
Take religion.
There is an enormous amount to:
study,
compare,
understand,
and explore.
History.
Belief.
Culture.
Tradition.
Meaning.
People can discuss religion seriously without requiring everybody to leave with the same conclusion.
Agreement is not always the objective.
Understanding may be enough.
One person may want to go very deep into a subject.
Another may only want a basic understanding.
That is fine.
Different desire levels.
Different destinations.
HAVING A POSITION
Politics works the same way.
Issues divide.
People choose sides.
Positions become identities.
Then suddenly…
questioning the position feels like questioning the PERSON.
That is where trouble begins.
You can have a position.
You should have a position when you have thought something through.
But your position does not require you to:
demean,
insult,
or silence
the person across from you.
The stronger your position is…
the less frightened it should be of examination.
PONDERING & REFLECTION
Some people do not want discussion.
They want conversion.
They arrive with an agenda.
Open or hidden.
They want to:
capture,
flood,
pressure,
or bombard
until the other person gives in.
That is not communication.
That is conquest.
What interests me more is introducing something worthwhile…
then leaving room.
Room for:
thought,
questions,
pondering,
reflection.
Sometimes the best conversation does not finish in the room.
It follows you home.
That is a good conversation.
THE TRUE TEST OF OBJECTIVITY
I remember college classes where highly emotional subjects were introduced.
People quickly divided into:
PRO
and
CON.
Hands went up.
Positions formed.
Everybody got comfortable.
Then came the surprise.
SWITCH SIDES.
LOL.
The PRO people had to argue CON.
The CON people had to argue PRO.
You should have heard the room.
Groans.
Complaints.
Murmuring.
A few deer-in-the-headlights looks.
Then laughter.
Then something useful happened.
People had to THINK.
Not simply defend what they already believed.
That is a very different exercise.
RESPECT THE SUBJECT MORE
If you really understand a subject…
you should be able to explain why the other side believes what it believes.
That does not mean you agree.
It means you listened.
There is maturity in being able to say:
I UNDERSTAND YOUR POINT.
I STILL DISAGREE.
That may be one of the most useful sentences in human communication.
No surrender.
No attack.
Just clarity.
TRY THIS TEST
Here is the test.
Take a subject you feel strongly about.
Now do three things:
State your position clearly.
State the strongest reasonable version of the opposing position.
Then explain where the two positions actually differ.
If you cannot do the second part…
you may not understand the disagreement as well as you think.
That is worth knowing.
ARGUMENT OFTEN HIDES INSECURITY
Sometimes people argue because they are not secure in their own position.
They need the other person to agree…
or they feel threatened.
Why?
If you believe something after careful thought…
another person’s disagreement does not erase it.
You can hear them.
Consider them.
Maybe even learn from them.
And still say:
NO.
I SEE IT DIFFERENTLY.
That is strength.
LISTENING IS NOT SURRENDER
This is another mistake.
People think if they listen too carefully…
they are giving ground.
Nonsense.
Listening simply means:
I AM WILLING TO UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU ARE SAYING.
That is not agreement.
It is discipline.
In fact…
good listening may strengthen your own position because now you understand what you are actually responding to.
THE PROFESSIONAL SIDE
This matters in business too.
Teams disagree.
Partners disagree.
Clients disagree.
Employees disagree.
Good organizations do not eliminate disagreement.
They use it.
Different viewpoints can expose:
risk,
weakness,
blind spots,
better options.
But that only works when people can disagree without turning the room toxic.
That is where courtesy becomes productive.
THE SOCIAL SIDE
In personal life…
the stakes can feel even higher.
Family.
Friends.
Marriage.
Long relationships.
If every disagreement becomes a battle…
people eventually stop being honest.
Why?
Because truth becomes too expensive to share.
That is not good rapport.
That is silence produced by fear of conflict.
Better to build a relationship where someone can say:
I DON’T AGREE WITH YOU.
And the answer can be:
OKAY.
TELL ME WHY.
That is healthy.
RICHIE SPEAKS
Here is one Richie rule:
If disagreement automatically becomes argument…
somebody stopped listening.
Another:
You do not need to defeat the person to defend the point.
And one more:
The real test of objectivity is whether you can explain the other side fairly.
PEARLS FROM THE BOOKS
From the spirit of Pearls for the Soul:
“Understanding does not require agreement, but it does require attention.”
From the spirit of God I AM:
“Truth is not threatened by sincere examination.”
From the spirit of It Is Finished:
“Release the need to win the person when the real opportunity is to understand the issue.”
PEARLS INSIGHT
Constructive disagreement depends on separating:
the person,
the position,
and the problem.
Healthy dialogue allows people to:
question,
clarify,
challenge,
and reconsider
without attacking personal worth.
One useful sign of genuine understanding is the ability to describe an opposing position accurately enough that the other person says:
YES.
THAT IS WHAT I MEAN.
Only then are you really disagreeing with THEM…
instead of arguing with your own version of what they said.
PEARLS CONNECTION
This connects directly with RAPPORT OPENS ALL DOORS…FOR US TO WALK THROUGH.
Rapport makes disagreement safer.
It also connects with ASSUME NOTHING IN TODAY’S WORLD…YOU MUST KNOW OR DON’T KNOW.
Do not argue against something the other person never actually said.
And PEOPLE WHO KNOW THEIR BUSINESS TALK TO THE POINT reminds us that clarity reduces unnecessary conflict.
FINAL SAY
Can you disagree and not argue?
TEST IT.
Take something you care about.
Listen to the other side.
Do not interrupt.
Do not prepare your rebuttal while they are still talking.
Ask questions.
Repeat their position back fairly.
Then state yours.
If both of you still disagree?
Fine.
The conversation may still have succeeded.
Because success is not always:
YOU AGREED WITH ME.
Sometimes success is:
WE BOTH LEFT UNDERSTANDING MORE THAN WHEN WE ARRIVED.
That is dialogue.
That is maturity.
That is respect.
Disagree if you must.
Argue only if you have forgotten what the conversation was for.
— Richie
Pearls for the Soul
when you feed the soul, you feed everything.
https://pearlsforthesoul.com
Been expecting you