Everybody’s doing it.
Interesting.
But before you join them…
Ask:
IS EVERYBODY RIGHT?
History is full of things that were:
Popular.
Accepted.
Normal.
Recommended.
And eventually discovered to be terribly wrong.
The crowd can show you what is common.
IT CANNOT GUARANTEE WHAT IS WISE.
There is a phrase that has influenced more human behavior than people probably realize:
EVERYBODY’S DOING IT.
Really?
Everybody?
And even if they are…
Why should that automatically become a reason for ME to do it?
That question deserves considerably more attention.
GO BACK IN HISTORY
For centuries, bloodletting was used as a medical treatment for many illnesses.
Highly educated people practiced it.
Doctors recommended it.
Influential people received it.
It belonged to accepted medical thinking for a very long time.
Today, we understand that removing blood indiscriminately from a sick person can obviously make many conditions worse.
Interesting lesson.
An idea does not become correct simply because educated, powerful, respected, or numerous people believe it.
STOP AND ASK
Whenever society begins saying:
THIS IS WHAT EVERYBODY DOES…
PAUSE FOR CAUSE.
Ask:
Why?
What evidence supports it?
What are the risks?
Who benefits?
What happens later?
Is this good for me?
Does this fit my values?
Those questions can save you considerable trouble.
COMMON SENSE STILL DESERVES A SEAT
If somebody is bleeding badly…
The immediate concern is usually:
CONTROL THE BLEEDING.
That makes intuitive sense.
Protect.
Stabilize.
Clean.
Repair.
Heal.
So when an accepted practice seems to contradict both evidence and sound reasoning…
LOOK AGAIN.
Not because common sense is always enough.
It isn’t.
But neither should we surrender judgment simply because somebody says:
TRUST US. EVERYBODY DOES THIS.
MIND YOUR OWN BUSINESS
By that I mean:
THINK FOR YOURSELF.
Listen to experts.
Absolutely.
Learn.
Research.
Ask people with knowledge.
But in the end, you are still responsible for decisions affecting:
Your health.
Your money.
Your relationships.
Your career.
Your family.
Your future.
You can respect another person’s knowledge without renting them your entire mind.
I WILL HEAR YOU OUT
That is a useful position.
Tell me.
Explain it.
Show me.
What is the evidence?
What happened to others who did it?
What are the alternatives?
I will listen.
But eventually…
I HAVE TO MAKE THE DECISION.
That is responsibility.
INDEPENDENCE IS PERSONAL TOO
There is something valuable in the idea of independence beyond national history.
An independent person can hear the crowd…
Without automatically joining it.
They can say:
I understand what everyone else is doing.
Now let me determine what makes sense for ME.
That is not rebellion for rebellion’s sake.
That is judgment.
MONEY CAN MAKE “EVERYBODY’S DOING IT” VERY EXPENSIVE
I saw versions of this in real estate.
Homeowners were encouraged to access equity.
Home equity lines of credit became attractive because suddenly money locked inside the house could be converted into spending power.
Vacation?
Possible.
Car?
Possible.
College?
Possible.
Improvements?
Possible.
Second property?
Maybe.
The temptation was obvious.
Why wait?
BORROWING AGAINST THE HOUSE CHANGES THE EQUATION
There is nothing inherently wrong with a HELOC.
Used prudently, it can be a legitimate financial tool.
But it is debt secured by your home.
That matters.
If somebody treats home equity like free money…
It is not free.
The house is helping guarantee the obligation.
So the correct question was never:
IS EVERYBODY GETTING ONE?
It was:
DOES THIS DEBT MAKE FINANCIAL SENSE FOR ME?
Huge difference.
VANITY CAN JOIN THE PARTY
Human beings like things.
I know.
Cars.
Trips.
Clothes.
Toys.
Homes.
Experiences.
Nothing automatically wrong with enjoying them.
But when easy credit begins saying:
YOU CAN HAVE IT ALL RIGHT NOW…
another voice should ask:
AT WHAT COST?
Future money is still money.
Borrowed money is still borrowed.
Eventually somebody wants repayment.
THE TITANIC LESSON
People love certainty.
“Can’t fail.”
“Can’t sink.”
“Can’t lose.”
Whenever language becomes that confident…
I become interested.
Because reality has a remarkable way of humbling certainty.
The Titanic is remembered partly because it became a symbol of confidence colliding with reality.
The lesson is not:
NEVER TAKE RISKS.
The lesson is:
DO NOT LET CONFIDENCE ELIMINATE CAUTION.
POPULAR DOES NOT MEAN SAFE
Smoking gives us another obvious example.
For generations, cigarettes were culturally normal.
Advertised heavily.
Used socially.
Associated with sophistication.
Eventually overwhelming evidence demonstrated serious health risks.
The crowd had been doing it.
The crowd was still wrong about the safety.
That alone should teach us something.
ALCOHOL
Alcohol offers a more nuanced example.
Many adults drink moderately without developing alcohol-use problems.
But:
EVERYBODY DRINKS
is still a terrible reason for YOU to drink.
If something harms your judgment…
Your health…
Your relationships…
Your responsibilities…
Then what everybody else is doing becomes irrelevant.
You are living YOUR life.
DRIVING
Same principle.
Traffic moves fast.
Everybody around you is speeding.
Fine.
Does that make the danger disappear?
No.
Crowds can normalize risk.
That is one of the traps.
When enough people do something, abnormal behavior can begin looking normal.
Reality does not necessarily cooperate.
MONEY AND INVESTING
Investing should not be lumped together with reckless behavior.
Responsible investing can be a legitimate way to build long-term wealth.
But another kind of crowd behavior appears here:
EVERYBODY’S MAKING MONEY.
NOW people rush in.
Price goes up.
Excitement increases.
Fear of missing out arrives.
Then judgment gets replaced by imitation.
That is the danger.
Not investment itself.
FOLLOWING WITHOUT UNDERSTANDING.
SEX AND THE CROWD
Sex is another place where:
EVERYBODY’S DOING IT
can exert enormous pressure.
Especially on younger people.
But what does everybody else’s behavior have to do with:
Your readiness?
Your values?
Consent?
Commitment?
Pregnancy risk?
Sexually transmitted infections?
Emotional consequences?
Nothing.
Personal decisions deserve personal thought.
“EVERYBODY DOES IT” IS NOT CONSENT
This needs to be said clearly.
No person owes another sexual activity because:
Everybody does it.
Their friends do it.
Their previous partner did it.
They did it before.
None of those arguments matter.
Consent belongs to the people involved…
IN THAT MOMENT.
Anything else is pressure.
DISCIPLINE IS UNDERRATED
There are times when maturity looks like:
NO.
Not because the thing is evil.
Because it is wrong for YOU.
Wrong timing.
Wrong risk.
Wrong person.
Wrong financial situation.
Wrong motive.
That is what discipline does.
It protects tomorrow from today’s impulse.
SOCIAL PROOF IS POWERFUL
Human beings naturally watch other human beings.
Restaurant crowded?
Must be good.
Everyone buying something?
Maybe I need it.
Everyone laughing?
Maybe I should laugh.
Everyone investing?
I am missing out.
This tendency can be useful.
But it can also bypass judgment.
Crowds provide SOCIAL PROOF.
Not necessarily ACTUAL PROOF.
Remember the difference.
ASK WHO BENEFITS
This question is especially useful:
WHO BENEFITS IF I BELIEVE THIS?
If somebody tells you:
EVERYBODY NEEDS THIS…
And they happen to sell it?
Interesting.
Doesn’t automatically make them dishonest.
But now you know there is an incentive.
Look closer.
ADVERTISING UNDERSTANDS THE CROWD
Marketing frequently uses phrases like:
MOST POPULAR.
BEST SELLER.
EVERYONE LOVES IT.
TRENDING.
Why?
Because people take comfort in joining other people.
Fine.
But popularity answers:
WHAT ARE PEOPLE BUYING?
It does not answer:
WHAT DO I NEED?
Those are separate questions.
YOU DON’T HAVE TO SWIM AGAINST EVERY TIDE
Now let’s be fair.
This Pearl is not telling you:
IF EVERYBODY DOES IT, DO THE OPPOSITE.
That would be equally foolish.
Sometimes everybody stops at the red light because stopping is wise.
Sometimes widespread behavior exists because it works.
The point is not:
REJECT THE CROWD.
The point is:
DO NOT OUTSOURCE YOUR JUDGMENT TO IT.
INVESTIGATE
When everybody is doing something…
Look.
Ask.
Study.
Consider.
Then decide.
Maybe you join them.
Maybe you don’t.
But either way…
YOU MADE THE DECISION.
That is the difference.
FOMO HAS EMPTIED MANY POCKETS
Fear of missing out is one of the crowd’s strongest weapons.
Everybody’s buying.
Everybody’s traveling.
Everybody has the new thing.
Everybody’s investing.
Everybody’s upgrading.
Everybody’s living better than me.
Really?
Social comparison can make ordinary contentment suddenly feel like failure.
Be careful.
The person trying desperately to keep up with everybody may eventually lose track of themselves.
REMEMBER THE JONESES
Keeping up with the Joneses has been around forever.
Today the Joneses have social media.
Now you can compare your ordinary Tuesday afternoon with somebody else’s edited highlight reel from Tahiti.
Wonderful system for creating dissatisfaction.
Look if you want.
Enjoy.
But don’t forget:
YOU ARE NOT LIVING THEIR LIFE.
THE WELL-TRAVELED ROAD
Sometimes the well-traveled road is well traveled because it is good.
Sometimes because everybody followed the person ahead of them.
You have to find out which.
That requires awareness.
FINAL THOUGHT
“Everybody’s doing it” tells you one thing:
A lot of people may be doing it.
That is all.
It does NOT tell you:
It is wise.
It is safe.
It fits you.
It will work.
It is moral.
It is financially sound.
It will still look intelligent ten years from now.
So listen to the crowd.
Watch what happens.
Learn from other people’s experience.
But keep ownership of your mind.
Sometimes the crowd will be right.
Sometimes terribly wrong.
And sometimes the smartest person in the room is simply the one willing to ask:
WHY?
PEARLS INSIGHT
Social proof strongly influences human behavior because people naturally use others’ choices as information about what is acceptable, desirable, or safe. Popularity, however, is not equivalent to evidence. Better decisions come from evaluating risks, incentives, facts, individual circumstances, long-term consequences, and personal values rather than automatically imitating majority behavior.
PEARLS FROM THE BOOKS
A recurring principle throughout Pearls for the Soul is:
ASK WHY.
The crowd says:
COME THIS WAY.
Fine.
Why?
What is there?
Who went before me?
How did it work out?
What does it cost?
You are allowed to investigate before you follow.
In fact…
YOU SHOULD.
PEARLS CONNECTION
This Pearl connects directly with:
RULE PLAYER OR RULE SLAYER… HOW DO YOU PLAY?
WHAT ONE PERSON CAN DO… ANOTHER CAN DO TOO
and
MY GREATEST FAILURE: DEFECTIVE THINKING… AND THE CURE
One examines rules.
One learns from other people’s success.
One warns against believing our own thinking without examination.
This Pearl completes the picture:
DO NOT BLINDLY FOLLOW YOURSELF…
OR THE CROWD.
Examine both.
RICHIE SPEAKS
Everybody’s doing it?
SO WHAT?
Tell me:
Does it make sense?
Does it work?
What’s the risk?
Who benefits?
What happens later?
If the answers look good…
Fine.
JOIN THEM.
If they don’t…
Stand there alone if you have to.
One person thinking clearly beats a thousand people running in the wrong direction.
FINAL SAY
The crowd can give you information.
Do not give it authority over your life.
Listen.
Watch.
Investigate.
Then make your own decision.
Because:
EVERYBODY’S DOING IT
has never been proof that everybody knows what they’re doing.
— Richie
Pearls for the Soul
when you feed the soul, you feed everything.
pearlsforthesoul.com
Been expecting you